How to Make Homemade Butter

How to Make Homemade Butter

You can’t beat the freshness and full flavour of homemade butter. Follow our easy recipe to whip up your own batch of homemade butter and cultured butter.

Making your own homemade butter can not only save you money on your grocery bill and avoid plastic packaging, but allows you to experience the flavour and freshness of homemade dairy that will far surpass anything you can buy from the store.

Homemade butter

Ingredients

• 500 mls cream

Method

1. Source the best quality cream you can find with the highest milk fat content, preferably 35%, with no additives or thickeners.

2. If you’re into low-tech, add cream to a jar with a tight-fitting lid and shake it well till it separates. This can take anywhere from five to thirty minutes.

3. Alternatively, if you have a food processor, pour in the cream and process until the cream goes past the whipped stage and separates into buttermilk and butter.

churning butter

4. Pour off the buttermilk and save it to use in pancakes and scones. Also makes a healthy drink.

5. Add some cold water to your food processor (or jar) and mix the butter again to wash it. Pour off the water and place your butter in a storage container. Paddle it a bit with spoons to release the rest of the buttermilk.

6. Add salt if you wish (salt will help it keep longer). Use around 1 tsp of salt per litre of cream. Store in the fridge for more longevity, or at room temperature if it’s salted.

Cultured butter

Culture your cream before making butter and you will end up with cultured butter – butter with a delicious tang and complex flavour. Most butter made in Australia is called sweet butter, whereas butter made in Europe is often cultured.

Ingredients

  • 500mls cream
  • 2 tbsp of cultures – could be buttermilk, yoghurt or kefir grains (or ¹⁄₈ tsp of mesophilic cheese cultures)

homemade butter cake

Method

1. Pour cream into a clean jar and add the cultures.

2. Put the lid on the jar and leave it on the bench for at least 24 hours. The longer you leave it, the more sour it will become.

3. If you used kefir grains, strain them out now.

4. Follow the instructions for making butter.

You can find the full version of this article in issue #15 of Pip Magazine, available here.

Like more articles like this one? Subscribe to Pip Magazine’s print or digital editions here.

Comments (6)

  1. Avatar

    Hi – this could not have come at a better time! The butter I like to buy is $5.50 for 250 grams – so I decided to go without. There are cheaper alternatives, but I don’t like all the extra additives the producers put into the product.
    Why do they add extra vitamins into butter – that’s just weird!
    I will be making butter this weekend for a fraction of the cost of the brand I usually buy.
    Thanks,
    eve

    Eve
    Mar 13, 2020 Reply
  2. […] have videos on growing and foraging for food, making household staples like sourdough bread, butter and cheese. We’ll also look into to managing your own waste, mending, as well as making […]

  3. Avatar

    Do you put the salt in at the beginning ? And how much butter does 500 ml of cream make please?

    Marise
    May 5, 2020 Reply
    • Avatar

      Salt goes in after the butter has been paddled. You don’t need to add salt, but it does add flavour and act as a preservative. 500ml of cream will make about 100gms of butter. You will get a better yield if you culture your cream first (add cultures such as milk kefir grains, and leave on the bench for 24 hours) before making it into butter.

      Robyn Rosenfeldt
      May 5, 2020 Reply
  4. Avatar

    I’ve cultured cream by adding whey (separated from milk kefir). Do all methods result in much the same tasting cream?

    Kerrie Girdo
    May 7, 2020 Reply
    • Avatar

      The taste of your cultured cream will depend on what cultures you use, how long you cultured it for, and the warmth of your kitchen. Generally you culture cream on the bench for 12-24 hours. The longer you leave it, the more sour it will taste. Taste your cultured cream a few times while culturing it to get the taste you prefer.

      Robyn Rosenfeldt
      May 8, 2020 Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *